Independent Insurance Agent, Grand Junction, CO

Nonprofit Insurance in Colorado

Nonprofits carry most of the exposures a business does, plus a few of their own: a volunteer board making decisions, volunteers doing the work, donated funds under stewardship, and often vulnerable people being served. The insurance has to reflect that rather than treat the organization as a small business with a different tax status.

Bird Family Insurance works with nonprofits across Grand Junction, Fruita, Palisade, Delta, Montrose, and Rifle. As an independent agency, we compare markets that understand nonprofit exposures rather than fitting a charity into a standard commercial package.

Use our form or call us at (970) 549-2500 to get your quote.

Licensed in CO & AZ

Fully Independent

SIAA & Trusted Choice Member

Free, no-obligation quotes

Where nonprofits differ from small businesses

Three things change the insurance picture, and all three are easy to underestimate.

A volunteer board makes binding decisions. Directors and officers can face claims arising from those decisions, and unlike a company board, nonprofit directors are typically unpaid people who joined to help.

Volunteers do the work. They can be injured, and they can cause harm to others, and neither situation is automatically handled the way employee exposures are.

The money is somebody else’s. Nonprofits hold donated and granted funds, and that stewardship attracts both scrutiny and, occasionally, theft.

Key point: The coverage nonprofits most often lack is directors and officers liability, and it is the one that protects the individuals who volunteered to serve. Property and general liability protect the organization; D&O protects the people running it.

Registration and the regulatory backdrop

If your organization solicits donations in Colorado, registration sits with the Secretary of State rather than with the Division of Insurance.

The Colorado Secretary of State administers charitable solicitation registration under the Colorado Charitable Solicitations Act, Title 6, Article 16 of the Colorado Revised Statutes, and maintains a searchable database of registered charities and fundraisers. Out-of-state nonprofits soliciting in Colorado are directed to file a Statement of Foreign Entity Authority before registering for a charitable solicitation licence.

That is a compliance obligation rather than an insurance one, but the two interact: grantmakers and funders frequently ask for evidence of both registration and insurance, and a lapse in either can hold up funding.

What a nonprofit usually needs

At a glance: General liability, directors and officers, property, workers’ compensation, volunteer coverage, and fidelity or crime. Availability and terms vary by activity and by who you serve.

Directors and officers liability

D&O coverage responds to claims against the board and officers arising from their decisions: allegations of mismanagement, breach of duty, conflicts of interest, employment decisions, or failure to follow the organization’s own governing documents.

For a nonprofit, the practical argument is simple. Good board members are hard to recruit, and capable people are reluctant to accept personal exposure for volunteering. Many will ask whether the organization carries D&O before they agree to serve.

General liability

Responds to third-party bodily injury and property damage, including at your premises, at events, and at activities you run off site. Fundraisers, festivals, and community events are where nonprofits generate liability exposure disproportionate to their size, and venues generally require evidence of coverage.

Property

Covers your building if you own one, and in every case your contents, equipment, and any donated goods you hold. Organizations running thrift operations or holding donated stock frequently underinsure this, because the value accumulates without anyone revaluing it.

Workers’ compensation

The Colorado Department of Labor and Employment states that employers must carry workers’ compensation insurance with one or more employees, regardless of whether they are part-time, full-time, or family members, and that anyone who gets paid for the work they perform is presumed to be an employee.

Nonprofits with any paid staff, including part-time coordinators, fall inside that requirement. Whether and how volunteers are treated is a separate question worth raising with us directly, because it depends on the arrangement rather than on the label.

Fidelity and crime

Where an organization handles donated funds, fidelity coverage responds to theft by someone with access, including staff and volunteers. Funders and grant agreements sometimes require it, and boards have a stewardship argument for carrying it regardless.

Coverages specific to what you do

Professional liability, where you provide advice, counselling, or clinical services
Event coverage, including liquor liability if alcohol is served at fundraisers
Cyber liability, since donor records are exactly the personal data Colorado’s breach notification duties attach to
Hired and non-owned auto, for staff and volunteers driving their own vehicles on the organization’s business

Who this coverage is for

Community and social service organizations
Faith-based organizations and churches
Youth and sports programs
Arts, museums, and cultural organizations
Food banks and thrift operations
Foundations and grantmaking bodies
Associations and member organizations

What affects your premium

Nonprofit pricing reflects activity more than size. It is generally shaped by what your organization actually does, who it serves, whether you work with vulnerable populations, your annual budget and revenue, paid staff and volunteer numbers, whether you own or lease premises, your event programme, your claims history, and the limits you choose.

The parts you can influence:

Board governance. Minutes, conflict-of-interest policies, and financial controls are read by D&O underwriters.
Financial controls. Dual signatures and segregation of duties support both fidelity coverage and good stewardship.
Describe your activities fully. Undisclosed programmes are how coverage gaps appear, and nonprofits often forget to mention the annual event.

Nonprofit exposures are underwritten differently from ordinary commercial risks, which is why comparing markets that understand them is worth doing.

How to get a nonprofit insurance quote

As an independent agency, we compare what is available for nonprofit exposures.

Tell us what the organization does

Mission, programmes, who you serve, and your annual budget.

Tell us about people and premises

Paid staff, volunteer numbers, board size, whether you own or lease, and your event programme.

We shop the market and you choose

You see general liability, D&O, property, and pricing side by side.

Ready for a quote? Use the form at the top of this page, or request a quote here. Prefer to talk it through? Call us at (970) 549-2500.

Get a Nonprofit Insurance Quote

We’ve Helped Locals Save Thousands On Their Insurance Policies

We’re The Trusted Choice For Western Colorado

“Marissa at Bird Family is Amazing!! She is fast and friendly when she is working on my business. Marissa and everyone at Bird Family always exceeds my expectations.”

Bonnie H

Google Reviews

“Marissa was so very helpful, addressing all my questions with kindness & patience. Bird Family gave me excellent coverage at a good price. I look forward to doing business with them.”

Kim M

Google Reviews

“Great company that seems to keep their customers needs at the forefront. I hadn’t checked pricing on my old insurer for many years, that was a mistake. … this agency saved me a TON of money with better coverages on both homeowners and our two vehicles. …”

John M

Google Reviews

Frequently Asked Questions About Nonprofit Insurance in Western Colorado

Does our nonprofit board need directors and officers insurance?

It is the coverage we would raise first. D&O responds to claims against the board and officers arising from their decisions, including allegations of mismanagement, breach of duty, conflicts of interest, employment decisions, or failure to follow the governing documents. Because nonprofit directors are typically unpaid volunteers, D&O protects the individuals rather than the organization, and capable board candidates increasingly ask whether it is in place before agreeing to serve.

Are our volunteers covered by our insurance?

It depends on the coverage and the situation, which is why it is worth working through rather than assuming. General liability may respond where a volunteer causes harm to a third party, but injury to the volunteer themselves is a different question, and workers’ compensation is written around employees. The Colorado Department of Labor and Employment treats anyone paid for work performed as presumed to be an employee, so the arrangement matters more than the title. Tell us how your volunteers operate and we will explain what responds.

Do we need to register with the state to fundraise in Colorado?

Charitable solicitation registration is handled by the Colorado Secretary of State under the Colorado Charitable Solicitations Act, Title 6, Article 16 of the Colorado Revised Statutes, and out-of-state nonprofits are directed to file a Statement of Foreign Entity Authority before registering. That is a compliance matter rather than an insurance one, but funders often ask for evidence of both registration and insurance, so a lapse in either can delay funding.

Do we need workers’ compensation if we only have one part-time employee?

Yes. The Colorado Department of Labor and Employment states that employers must carry workers’ compensation with one or more employees, and that this applies regardless of whether they are part-time, full-time, or family members. There is no threshold to grow into, so a single part-time coordinator brings the requirement with them.

Does our insurance cover our annual fundraising event?

Sometimes, and sometimes not, which is why it should be raised rather than assumed. Off-site events, temporary venues, and alcohol service can all fall outside a standard general liability policy, and venues usually require evidence of coverage naming them. If alcohol is served, liquor liability is a separate consideration. Tell us about your event programme when we quote rather than the week before the event.